"I can't do it," my soon-to-be
13-year-old daughter wailed
hysterically. "I'll make mistakes. I'll
be humiliated."
It was midnight
meltdown. Part of the bat mitzvah
preparation process.
Why do we do this to our kids? Thirteen.
The worst possible age. Everything is
changing -- bodies, voices and
allegiances. Couldn't this ritual be
postponed a couple of years until things
settle down? Why now?
"Bar and bat mitzvahs are
developmentally well-placed," says
Berkeley
psychiatrist Lester Isenstadt. "It
really has to do with a transition from
being a child to being an adult and
starting to go into the world."
And there's no avoiding it. The
transition happens with or without the
formal ceremony. But the bar and bat
mitzvah ritual brings this shift to a
higher awareness, creating the
opportunity to deal with the feelings it
evokes.
"Anxieties of this stage have a lot to
do with how the self is perceived by
others," Isenstadt says. "What the
ritual is trying to convey is that being
guided by internal standards is more
important than how others perceive you."
According to Isenstadt, bar and bat
mitzvahs bring out the best in everyone.
"It's a developmental challenge most
youngsters can cope with and benefit
from," Isenstadt says. "It consolidates
the child's sense of self as a competent
youngster."
In almost 30 years of treating
adolescents, as well as their parents,
Isenstadt has never seen a child fail at
this task. Children feel very supported
by their parents, the rabbi and the
community.
They also learn a valuable lesson. You
don't have to be perfect.
Rabbi Steven Chester of
Oakland's
Temple
Sinai
routinely tells students before the
ceremony it's OK if they make mistakes.
Isenstadt contrasts bar and bat mitzvahs
with less-healthy initiations, which
often convey psychologically misleading
and poor illusions of what's necessary
for success. Like by making a certain
team or getting into the right college
or club, some children believe they're
winners for life. Or by failing to make
cheerleader, prom queen or honor choir,
they're automatically losers.
Fortunately, life is not that simple.
"Whether you're trying to be a good
person, professional or parent, we all
know these tasks involve lifelong
effort. Bar and bat mitzvahs are a first
step," Isenstadt says. "They prepare
youngsters for the actual challenges and
frustrations of what's ahead."
|
|
Such assurances aside, the day after my
daughter's
midnight
meltdown, I was on the phone with a
friend. I knew my daughter would be
fine, but I was another story.
"I'll never get everything done," I
said. "What if there's not enough food?
What if no one comes?"
Our invitations had been out for a week
and only a few RSVPs had trickled in.
The fear that my daughter's friends, my
friends, our family wouldn't show up
crippled me with anxiety.
Bar and bat mitzvahs "stir up in parents
the anxieties they experienced at that
phase of their own development,"
Isenstadt says.
Ah yes, my own confirmation party. It
was the worst of times; new school, few
friends and zits galore.
This was my coming out, too -- my first
adult, catered party. What about the
family? They'll be judging me. What if
they're disappointed?
"Friends and relatives are not expecting
perfection," Isenstadt says. "[They]
love you for who you really are, for
bringing a child to this point."
I hope Isenstadt is right.
The morning of the bat mitzvah my
daughter was calm. I was short of
breath, wondering if anxiety had ever
killed anyone. I felt as if I were
standing on the edge of a precipice.
Bar and bat mitzvahs, Isenstadt says,
"are transitions for parents, too. They
represent a change from being parents of
very young children to parents of people
who are growing up and getting ready to
leave home."
So this is separation anxiety. Hers and
mine. Any advice?
"Don't let the synergy of shared anxiety
blow the roof off the house," Isenstadt
says. "It's important for parents to
stay developmentally ahead of the
child."
My daughter was wonderful -- poised and
confident. She made a mistake or two and
laughed about them later with friends.
And there was plenty of food at the
party.
The following Monday, she was still a
seventh-grader, but not quite the same
person she was the week before.
Fortunately there's still a driver's
license, PSATs, SATs, confirmation and
who knows what else before she graduates
and leaves home.
If I run real fast for the next few
years, maybe I can stay one step ahead
of her.
Originally written in 1994 for the
Jewish Bulletin of Northern California
Ronnie Caplane is a lawyer and activist
in
California.
She is a nationally renown
freelance writer.
RonnieCaplane@comcast.net
|